InSinkErator Badger 1 Vs Badger 5 [Which One Should I Buy?]

badger 5 vs badger 1

We compare Badger 1 vs Badger 5 and discuss some features that distinguish them from each other. However, we can understand the comparison well if we have some basic information regarding the structure and working of garbage disposals. Also, we know badger 1 or Badger 5 is suitable for us or not?

As we know that the purpose of installing garbage disposal is to avoid the blockage and obstruction of the drainage systems and to get rid of unpleasant odors. In other words, garbage disposals help you maintain a clean, peaceful, and luxurious environment in your kitchen.

When it comes to the selection of garbage disposal, there are several brands and series available. You can make a choice as per your needs and requirements. Thus, you will be able to choose the best garbage disposal for your kitchen sink.

Generally, the InSinkErator brand has two series of garbage disposals namely the badger and the evolution series. The badger series is of common use among the people due to its low price and effective working.


Differences Between Badger 1 And Badger 5:

Roughly speaking, these two products are almost similar to each other. The differences between these two garbage disposals are very few and slight in their nature. The differences on the basis of which these products are distinguished from each other are given below.

Motor Power:

The main and the most basic difference between these products is the motor power. The badger 1 has a motor of 1/3 horsepower which is considered to be a low power motor. And it is suitable for apartments having a small family.

For example, an apartment that has two or three persons will be suitable for its working & installation because it cannot sustain a heavy workload. While badger 5, on the other hand, has a motor of 1/2 horsepower which makes this garbage disposal comparatively more powerful and efficient.


Another thing that makes these products different from each other is the warranty. It is notable that badger 5 has a warranty of 3 years while badger 1, on the other hand, has a 2-year warranty. That’s why we can say that badger 5 is preferable in this regard.

Similarities Between Badger 5 And Badger 1:

It will be correct to say that these two products are similar to each other to a remarkable extent because of having a lot of similarities between them. The first notable thing that is similar between these two products is the material from which their grinding chambers are made of.

The components of their grind chambers are made up of galvanized steel. Galvanized steel makes the components more durable and this is what enhances the life span of these garbage disposals.

The grind chamber capacity of both these products is 26 oz, which also assists in dependable grinding of waste material by allowing the grinding of a large amount of waste at the same time.

Both these garbage disposals have dura-drive induction motors fitted into them. Although dura-drive induction motors are considered to be of old models, there is no doubt about their satisfactory performance.

Another thing similar between these products is that they both are continuous feed garbage disposals and help you by allowing you to put the waste into them at any time during your work in the kitchen.

Image Product Feature Price



Easy installation,
Dependable grinding,
Compact design
Check On Amazon



More durable,
Effective grinding,
Quick installation
Check On Amazon

1. InSinkErator Garbage Disposal, Badger 1, 1/3 HP Continuous Feed:

InSinkErator Garbage Disposal

Producer: InSinkErator
Product dimensions: 7x7x12 inches, 12.84 pounds weight
Motor power: 1/3 horsepower

Structure And Functioning:

The compact design and space-saving nature of this garbage disposal make it suitable for installation in even very small places. The motor installed in this product has a power of 1/3 horsepower that is comparatively low. However, the dura-drive induction motor performs its function more effectively and assists in waste disposal.

It is notable that this garbage disposal is compatible with the pre-installed hardware of the previous disposal unit, that’s why you need not install the new hardware. The components of the grinding chamber are made up of galvanized steel and play a key role in enhancing the durability of this product.

Additional Features:

This product has a grind chamber capacity of 26 oz which makes it suitable for large-scale working. In addition to it, this garbage disposal is a continuous feed which is also an addition to its reliability.

  • No need for new hardware
  • Continuous feed
  • Dependable grinding
  • Space-saving nature
  • Durable components
  • Low cost
  • Power cord not attached
  • Comparatively louder

Reviews From Customers:

The majority of the customers praised its compact size. Others appreciated its ease of installation because of its compatibility with the previously installed hardware. Some of the users complained that the product was not corrosion resistant and others disliked the absence of a power cord.

2. InSinkErator Garbage Disposal, Badger 5, 1/2 HP Continuous Feed:

InSinkErator Garbage Disposal Badger 5 HP Continuous Feed


Prominent Features:

  • More durable
  • Effective grinding
  • Quick installation

Producer: InSinkErator
Product dimensions:
6.31×6.31×11.5 inches, 13.52 pounds weight
Motor power:
½ horsepower

Structure And Functioning:

The ease of installation of this product makes it a more dependable and practical option. Similar to the badger 1, this product is also suitable for the previously installed hardware.

The motor having a power of ½ horsepower and a working speed of 1725 RPM helps in effective grinding and blockage resistance. It also makes the garbage disposal resistant to clogs. Galvanized steel components help in enhancing the reliability and durability of this product.

Additional Features:

The quick lock mount system adds more ease to the installation and replacement of this garbage disposal. When it comes to the grinding of waste material, the dura-drive induction motor provides dependable grinding.

This product is also a continuous feed garbage disposal along with 26 oz grind chamber capacity. All these features collectively make this garbage disposal a dependable solution to the drainage system problems of your kitchen sink.

  • Powerful motor
  • Quick-lock mount
  • Effective grinding
  • High-speed working
  • No need to install new hardware
  • 3-year warranty
  • Power cord not attached
  • Slightly bigger size

Reviews From Customers:

Users appreciated the quick installation because of the presence of a quick-lock mount. The users were also found happiness with the performance of the induction motor which provides you a quick and effective grinding.

Read: Top 15 Garbage Disposals

However, a few users claimed that they faced leakage problems while using this product. Some others complained about the rusting problem after 2-years of usage.

Badger 5 vs Badger 1, Which One Is Better?

1badgervs5badgerDespite remarkable similarities between these two, there are some aspects that make them different from each other. The main thing is which one of these two fits better to your needs and requirements. But Badger 5 is better product from badger 1 due to quick installation and realibility.

Read: Badger 5 Vs Badger 500

If you want garbage disposal to have a relatively powerful motor, you can go for badger 5. And in case you need a budget-friendly or low-cost garbage disposal, then you may opt for badger 1. And similar will be the case in other features.

Are Garbage Disposals Dangerous?

No, garbage disposals are not dangerous at all. They are safe to use, however, you need to use them with proper care and attention and avoid putting your hand into them.

How Does Garbage Disposals Work?

The working mechanism of garbage disposal is very simple. It simply crushes the solid waste with the help of a motor, blades, and impeller plates. This crushing of waste material helps to avoid clog formation and blockage.

What Is The Difference Between Continuous Feed And Batch Feed Garbage Disposal?

Batch feed garbage disposals don’t allow the continuous putting of waste into them. While continuous feed garbage disposals allow the continuous putting of waste into them as they keep working until plugged off.

Do Garbage Disposals Require And Maintenance?

No, the garbage disposals don’t require any maintenance. However, what you need to do is keep them cleaning after regular intervals. And you can do so by rinsing them with an adequate amount of water. It will help your garbage disposals greatly in clog resistance.

Is It Difficult To Install A Garbage Disposal?

No, installing garbage disposal is not a difficult task if you are a handy person. You can install the garbage disposal yourself easily if you have the necessary tools required for its installation.

How Much Time Garbage Disposal Takes To Crushing Waste Material?

Garbage disposals are very fast working and they do not take any time for the crushing of waste. You can estimate the fast working of garbage disposals from the fact that they perform their work in just a few seconds.


Choosing the right garbage disposal for your kitchen sink is a matter of prime concern if you want to maintain a comfortable environment in your kitchen. Two products of the badger series reviewed in this badger 1 vs badger 5 article are worth choosing due to their unique features and affordable prices.

Choosing one of these two products totally depends upon your needs. If you find badger 5 garbage disposal compatible with your requirements, you can go for it. Otherwise, you can choose badger 1.

Leave a Comment